Which Is Better – Chain Drive or Belt Drive Garage Door Opener?
Automatic garage doors look modern, are more aesthetic, and require less manual labor. So, if you are planning to install automated garage doors, then you are familiar with the range of options available in the market. Metal garages with automatic doors essentially feature chain-drive or belt-drive garage door openers.
These two garage door openers are utilized in 95% of the automatic door market. However, if you buy a new house, it is likely that you will get a chain-drive opener because belt-drive door openers are a relatively newer concept.
In comparison, they may seem similar, but they are different in how they operate, how much they cost, and their load-bearing capacity.
Chain-Drive vs Belt-Drive: How They Function
Chain-drive garage door openers use a chain and a trolley system to pull up and lower down the garage door. A steel chain, similar to a bike chain, usually runs along the rail, which is wrapped around the door opener’s sprocket. The chain is also connected to a separate idle sprocket located on the other end of the rail. A trolley moves along the rail — back and forth — operating the door. The chain moves a J-arm and a carriage to close and open the door.
Belt-drive garage door openers, however, utilize a rubber belt to move a trolley to open and close the door. The belt runs along a rail and can be reinforced with steel for additional strength. The rubber belt moves along a track, effectively controlling the motion of the door. Belt-drive door openers are also considered to be more sleek and aesthetically pleasing.
What are the Major Factors to Consider When Installing a New Garage Door?
Before you invest in a new garage door opener, there are several factors to consider in order to make the right choice.
- Evaluate the size of your steel garage door.
- How often do you use the door?
- What is the proximity of your garage to your house and bedroom?
- Would you require Wi-Fi-enabled monitoring?
- Does the garage door opener come with a battery backup?
In-Depth Analysis
While their functionality might be alike, chain-drive and belt-drive garage door openers differ in a wide range of ways. These differences might help you in making a firm decision in choosing the right garage opener to meet your usage requirements.
| Categories | Chain-drive | Belt-drive |
| Cost | Chain-drive garage door openers are not just more economical but also are widely available.
They can cost anywhere between $150 and $400. |
Belt-drive garage door openers are on the more expensive side, but they turn out to be a more economical option in the long run.
They cost anywhere between $200 and $500. |
| Strength | These are strong enough to bear the load of residential as well as commercial garage doors.
For heavier garage doors or, in the case of a two-door garage, these work better. |
These can bear the load of residential garage doors.
However, if your garage door is heavy or insulated, belt-drive openers are not the right choice because of their low lifting capacity. |
| Noise | Chains are made of metal, and they are pulled up by metal parts, too. Since these grind against each other, the metal-on-metal friction leads to loud noises.
Hence, if your garage is located closer to your house or bedroom, installing these could be an issue. |
Belt-drive openers are quieter and ideal for small garages located near your house. As these use rubber material, they operate smoothly.
There is also a significant decrease in vibration. In case your door still makes a noise, it is most likely an alignment and balance issue. |
| Maintenance | Chain-drive openers are likely to incur more maintenance costs as they have to be lubricated at least twice a year in order to function correctly. They are also susceptible to catching rust.
If they aren’t maintained well, they can suffer significant wear and tear and reduce the lifespan of your door openers. You should also check for chain slack, which is the amount of chain movement possible, and tighten the screws if required. The maintenance can cost between $50 and $100. However chain replacements, required every few years, can cost $150 to $250. |
These do not require constant maintenance. You might need to adjust the mechanism in case the rubber belt stretches or ends up slipping.
However, belt-drive systems are affected by heat and humidity. So, you might have to change or tighten the belt in extreme temperatures. You can further lower the maintenance issues with belt-drive door openers by insulating your garage. Their maintenance cost can range from $40 to $80. Belt replacements, required every 5 to 8 years, can cost $200 to $300. |
| Speed | These functions slightly at a lower speed. | Belt-drive door openers are faster in comparison. |
| Durability | Chain-drive door openers are likely to wear down faster due to metal-to-metal contraction.
However, with proper lubrication and maintenance, they can last longer than belt-drive as they aren’t even impacted by heat or humidity. |
In adverse weather conditions, belt-drive door openers are likely to wear out quicker.
Material, belt elasticity, and proper maintenance impact the lifespan of these openers. They also come with a better warranty than chain-drive systems. |
| Load-bearing capacity and horsepower | They usually have a load-bearing capacity of 750 lbs to 1000 lbs. With 3/4 or more horsepower, these can easily handle heavy-duty doors. | Belt-drive door openers have a load-bearing capacity of 500 lbs to 750 lbs. However, doors with 1 horsepower can handle heavier doors. |
| Ease of installation | Chain-drive door openers are heavier and require proper mechanics for installation. | These are lighter and, hence, easier to handle during installation. |
Garage Door Essentials: Advanced Features to Look for in 2024
As the technology is advancing at a faster pace, there are a few modern features to look for when installing garage doors:
- Automatic door reversing features can be installed either with electronic sensors or photoelectric eyes. They enhance the security of the garage.
- Keypads with keyless entry without the requirement of a remote or phone application.
- Rolling code technology will make it impossible for thieves to enter into your garage.
- Manual release will allow you to detach the garage door from the openers, allowing ease of opening in case of emergencies.
- Battery backup is another way to easily open the door in case of power outages.
- Safety sensors will prevent the doors of your garage from closing when an obstacle is blocking them.
- Overhead lights with sensors attached will turn on as soon as the garage door opener is functional.
- Horsepower is also a crucial aspect when installing a garage door opener. 1/2 horsepower openers work well with general doors. However, in the case of 3/4 or 1 1/4 horsepower, door openers are ideal for larger doors.
Which is the Best Garage Door Opener?
The perfect garage door opener for you will depend entirely on the size of your garage door, the garage’s proximity to your home, and your budget. Chain-drive garage openers are ideal if you don’t mind the loud noise and want a durable and cost-effective door opener. However, if you have a one-car garage situated closer to your house and you don’t mind the additional cost, then opt for a belt-drive garage door opener.
If you are looking to install cost-effective, easy-to-install, and customizable metal garages, invest in our detached garages. We at Viking Steel Structures offer insulated steel buildings that let you work and repair in peace without making excessive noise. Call 877-801-3263 for a free consultation and get a quote!
Looking for a metal building that fits your needs?
